Enabling Sidebar Stops Posts From Loading

I just love this plugin (which is why I’m posting this question rather than just deleting it) and I have installed a variety of sidebar plugins (like Super Socializer and Social Pug) without issue.

Social Warefare works in the standard Top/Bottom links format, and the sidebar *seems* to work fine when logged into WP, but once I try to load in a non-logged-in browser the Posts do not load – i.e. “white screen”.

The minute I disable the sidebar option on Posts, the pages immediately load, so it is definitely the sidebar interfering with the page load. I have tried all combinations of plugin settings, and disabled other plugins, but it still locks up when the sidebar drop-down is selected and saved. The standard top/bottom icons load no problem, it’s just that sidebar.

If you are familiar with this issue and know of any possible solutions (like custom CSS, etc.) please let me know.