I cannot login

I opened this WordPress with a now defunct email, but was sure to change my information. I get updates at my current email of plug-ins and what not. But I can not sign in whatsoever and I need to do updates to the site, but you guys do not recogonize any of my email addresses to change the password. What is going on here? I need access to my site.

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]