Really confused here…

Maybe I’m not understanding this plugin…
I wanted to do the same thing as above but not let “Subscribers” view BuddyPress information too. So buddypress users are only the Contributor role and above. I created what you suggested above but instead of Subscriber role, I started with Contributor role.

First, create a new Access Level, Subscribers, and add the conditions you want unregistered users not to see. E.g. a Group with some BuddyPress specific pages and a Group with BuddyPress Profile pages.
Sync this group with the Subcribers role and save it.

I repeated the second part

Now only Subscribers can see this content, so to make administrators able to see it as well, create another Access Level, Administrators.
Here you do not need to add any conditions, but sync with Administrator role and set the option Extend: Subscribers and save.

I added for all other roles except subscriber.

I have a member named “subscriber” who has Subscriber role. I log on as subscriber. If I go to the buddypress “members” page it displays. This page was included in the first access level created, the one all other access levels Extend to. If I am logged off and go to the same page it does not go to the page but just stays on the home page. It also displays the page for Not logged-in user either.

I also tried negating the conditions and applying it to “Not logged-in” and then extending it to Subscriber role and that doesn’t work either.

Any help is appreciated, thanks.