Specific user role un-activates users

I duplicated a role on WordPress, it’s completely identical to the original in that regard.
When I change the role to the new one, the account will become unactivated and a X will appear in the “Verified” column on our User list where a tick once was. When I revert the role back to anything else, the tick will appear again and the user will be able to log in once more.

This is such a strange issue? I’ve disabled pretty much all of my plugins to test for conflicts but nothing seems to working.