Add additional options

I’d like to be able to offer my customers the ability to pay by PayPal OR cash. Is there a way I can add a cash option without the plugin auto redirecting to PayPal? I have it set up like this right now:

[select select-468 “Pay with PayPal|paypal” “Pay by Cash”]

But when the customer chooses the cash option, they are still redirected to PayPal after a few seconds.

Thanks