• Resolved atomizer

    (@atomizer)


    1) STILL no categories/tags to help with sorting and FINDING media uploads
    2) gallery STILL inserting invalid style code
    3) gallery removing ‘columns=”0″‘
    4) no ‘0 columns’ choice in gallery UI
    5) no advanced options for inserting video – can’t even add a title, much less control size or POSITION
    6) in short, the majority of the media system is rudimentary at best
    7) TinyMCE STILL removing ‘p’ and ‘br’ tags!!! WTF?!?!?!
    8) lots of USEFUL TinyMCE plugins … disabled by default
    9) no internal function to check and notify of broken links – SEO? who cares, right?
    10) STILL no category tags for pages
    11) no option to add/remove custom thumbnail sizes
    12) for some reason it’s apparently a much better idea to generate a pile of thumbnails that may never be used at upload time instead of generating them AS NEEDED when they are inserted into a post
    13) and lucky #13 … wp-cron.php – need i even comment?

    either plugins or code hacks or both are needed to bring to WP what should be built-in and/or fixed at the core level and of course, with plugins, comes risk

Viewing 6 replies - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
  • Moderator James Huff

    (@macmanx)

    WordPress does not strive to be all things for all people. If it did that, it would be a bloated mess. Instead, the WordPress philosophy is to present the basics of what most people want, and to leave the rest to plugins.

    If WordPress comes missing 12 features that you absolutely need, you’re welcome to install and activate as many plugins as you need, that’s why there are currently 36,172 free plugins at https://ww.wp.xz.cn/plugins/ It’s much better than someone else getting 12 features they don’t need.

    1 – 6. There are a huge number of plugins for Media and Gallery Management. This is one of the most popular: https://ww.wp.xz.cn/plugins/nextgen-gallery/

    7. Make sure that you do your HTML editing in the Text editor tab, not the Visual tab.

    8. See at the start of this reply. If you want to enable them, no one will stop you.

    9. Plugin: https://ww.wp.xz.cn/plugins/broken-link-checker/

    10. Pages are considered static content which you link to in your site navigation, not something to be categorized like posts. Regardless, here’s a plugin: https://ww.wp.xz.cn/plugins/add-category-to-pages/

    11. Yes there is, visit Settings -> Media in your blog’s Dashboard.

    12. Disable thumbnail generation by setting the thumbnail dimensions at Settings -> Media in your blog’s Dashboard to 0.

    13. WordPress is developed by volunteers, and you’re welcome to help out if you think the cron system needs to be improved: https://make.ww.wp.xz.cn/core/handbook/the-wordpress-codebase/

    Thread Starter atomizer

    (@atomizer)

    no offense, but your answer is exactly the generic answer i was expecting

    i’m not asking that WP be all things to all people – i’m requesting that known problems and shortcomings be addressed

    who would NOT benefit from…
    * image categories/tags to help with sorting and finding media?
    * the elimination of invalid gallery styles?
    * the addition of ‘0 columns’ in the gallery UI?

    would any of these add any bloat to the code?

    it is bugs and shortcomings such as these that force users to install sometimes bloated and buggy alternatives that can create headaches for everyone

    and how many people have griped about WP removing p and br tags? would removing the code that strips the tags bloat the core? the answer “use the text editor” is not a solution to a problem – it is a workaround to an extremely annoying shortcoming for which yet another plugin is needed, or editing of the filters, both of which SHOULD NOT be necessary – who would gripe if these tags were not stripped, like any other html editor in existence?

    if you want to use the text editor, then you should be able to SEE THE CODE

    as for broken links, who would gripe about being notified about broken links? a majority, or a (very small) minority?

    as for assigning cats to pages, who cares if they are considered by WP to be static? should the guy searching for information on the www be aware whether he is a) searching a WP site and b) if so, whether the content is a page or post? all he is aware of is the fact that he clicked the “turtles” cat link and, in a website with 10000 pages about turtles, but no posts about turtles, nothing was returned. who considers that to be intuitive?

    disable thumbnail gen – that’s your answer to re-working an obvious disk space wasting problem? to break the functionality for many users? is that really a better solution than generating the thumbnails as they are needed?

    Moderator James Huff

    (@macmanx)

    no offense, but your answer is exactly the generic answer i was expecting

    No offense, but you won’t mind if I do take offense at that, right?

    who would NOT benefit from image categories/tags to help with sorting and finding media?

    People who don’t want the extra overhead of yet-another-thing to do during the upload process.

    who would NOT benefit from the elimination of invalid gallery styles?

    Those who aren’t encountering invalid gallery styles. (It’s probably your theme that’s doing it.)

    who would NOT benefit from the addition of ‘0 columns’ in the gallery UI?

    Those who just want a simple click-and-go gallery without the extra fuss.

    would any of these add any bloat to the code?

    Yes, they add extra code, and to the user they add more buttons and options, more things to do.

    it is bugs and shortcomings such as these that force users to install sometimes bloated and buggy alternatives that can create headaches for everyone

    You mean plugins, the things that generally only do one thing, and usually do it well, and are there so only the people who want that one thing can use it?

    and how many people have griped about WP removing p and br tags?

    Plenty. WordPress is volunteer developed, it would be great if one of those people stepped up to the plate: https://make.ww.wp.xz.cn/core/handbook/the-wordpress-codebase/

    as for broken links, who would gripe about being notified about broken links? a majority, or a (very small) minority?

    The majority of hosting providers. Scraping for broken links is very processor-intensive, not recommended on most shared hosting providers, and actually banned on a few.

    And, like I already said earlier, plugin: https://ww.wp.xz.cn/plugins/broken-link-checker/

    should the guy searching for information on the www be aware [about no tags on pages]

    If you actually have those words in your content, like any one focussing on SEO would, the “guy searching for information” will never notice. The search engines don’t care about tags, they care about content.

    And, like I already said earlier, plugin: https://ww.wp.xz.cn/plugins/add-category-to-pages/

    disable thumbnail gen – that’s your answer to re-working an obvious disk space wasting problem?

    No, that was my answer to “for some reason it’s apparently a much better idea to generate a pile of thumbnails that may never be used” meaning you can disable it and then generate your own thumbnails in your image editor of choice.

    Thread Starter atomizer

    (@atomizer)

    glad you finally were able to solve some of the problems many of us users have been griping about for years

    Moderator James Huff

    (@macmanx)

    I’ll just take that as “thank you!” and say that I’m glad I could help provide an alternative perspective. πŸ™‚

    Have a great day, and please let us know if you have any more questions!

    Moderator Ipstenu (Mika Epstein)

    (@ipstenu)

    πŸ³οΈβ€πŸŒˆ Advisor and Activist

    3) gallery removing ‘columns=”0″‘

    http://halfelf.org/2015/gallery-columns-zero/

    It’s not a perfect solution, but it works for what I need. I should probably sit down and actually submit it as a patch for core…

Viewing 6 replies - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)

The topic ‘Becoming disillusioned’ is closed to new replies.