Best Plugin for Comment Notifications

I’ve been searching for a comment notification plugin that is simple to use and works well for a long time, until I finally found this plugin that I think is the best solution out there!

I tried using Subscribe To Comments Reloaded, but it didn’t work with my theme and also it’s a little too feature-heavy – all I needed was a checkbox to follow comments and a way to unsubscribe. Another plugin I tried was Jetpack Comments, which did work, but the notification checkbox is opt-in, so visitors always have to check the checkbox if they want to be notified (which only very few do). And then I found some other plugins that focus more on helping moderators to keep track of new comments.

Finally I found Comment Notifier. I had a little trouble caused by another plugin, but got great and really quick help from Stefano (developer of Comment Notifier). Thanks so much!