Clearfy Delisted site from Google for 500 errors

I deactivated Clearfy a while ago, and some time around January 10th, even though the plugin was deactivated, it still gave 500 errors to Google which delisted us. So, today, I backed up the database, activated the plugin, set it to default settings, tried it still got an error in my error log, deactivated it, deleted it, and then went into the Options table and removed its autoload entries. I was able to ask Google to reindex that site. This was not Clearfy Pro. I would be happy to share my error log with you if you want it. Just thought I should mention this as a plugin should NOT be affecting a site when it’s deactivated.

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]