Comments link not working

I’ve got posts on a custom page but the comments link goes to:

/page-name/#respond

instead of

/page-name/post-name/#respond

The code for my custom page is:

http://wordpress.pastebin.com/HjmRPjca

And to compare, here’s the code for my Main Index Template where I got the comments link from:

http://wordpress.pastebin.com/LhZTHt1R

Why would the comments link work for the main index but not for my custom page template? It’s inside the loop, I believe, but it’s giving the link to the page it’s on instead of the posts link with #respond.

The pages in question are:

http://rockonpublishing.co.uk/ (main index with working comments link)
http://rockonpublishing.co.uk/rock-on-recommends/ (custom page where comments link doesn’t work properly)