Content Control with Password Protected plugin

Hi, I have 3 sets of users but am having trouble setting this up – can you please assist?

1) Logged out users can access all pages by entering one password (via the Password Protected plugin)

2) Logged in users with the “subscribers” role can ONLY view pages tagged “crave”. If they try to access another page, they are redirected back to their homepage http://www.eatallshop.com/crave/

3) Admins can see and edit everything

—

Right now I have it set up as the below but it isn’t working – it blocks access to all when logged in as a Subscriber

1) Allow Admin: Logged in Users with role Admin. Content “Is a page”.
2) Logged out can see all: Logged out users. Content “Is a page.”
3) Allow Crave: Logged in Users with role Subscriber. Content “Is a page with tag Crave”.

—

Is it an issue with the priority?
Also how do cookies/caching affect this? It seems that I can test it at different points and it acts differently even if I haven’t changed any settings.

Appreciate any advice. Thank you!

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]