Get a post

I am using Kaf’s get-a-post plugin.

It works fine on the site but on my box every instance of its use is showing up one specific ‘page’ and NOT the particular ‘posts’ that i am calling in different areas of the homepage.

I can’t figure out what can be the reason. The same sets of plugins are active both on the site as well as on my comp.

Could it have something to do with the Options?

EDIT:
There are many ‘pages’ on the site. It is the FIRST page (in terms of post ID) which is showing up in all distinct instances that I am calling “get-a-post”