HTTP vs HTTPS?

I have a website, kenedy.org which is using https and a local dev site at kenedy.dev. When I set up the invisible recaptcha and got my keys, I added both those domains to the domains list.

I then installed your plugin on both the production and dev site. I enabled the feature to protect the wordpress login page. When attempting to login on both sites I see the badge at the bottom left. Logging in worked on the development site, but not on the production site. They’re exact mirrors of each other. So my question is, does your plugin get affected by https?

I’m not getting any errors, the page acts like it’s going to login to the dashboard but instead the page refreshes and clears out the login form.

Any thoughts? Can I provide more information?