JS Version not working

Regular version works fine.

JS version doesn’t do anything UNLESS Restrict All Content radio is checked. Then it works but hides whole site.

I have Posts will inherit their taxonomies restriction settings checked

I enabled Age Gate on a category and on individual posts under that category.

I have Categories and Tags checked under Inheritance taxonomies.

I am testing incognito in Chrome. I do not use an ad blocker.

There are no JS errors in console.

If you can PM me I can give you log in deets.

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]