Missing options for advanced features

I am trying to do a 410 redirect on this page, and in trying, I realize I don’t have any advanced options under “Group.” I have only “Redirections” or “Modified Posts” as options, and no cog to choose advanced options. When using the plugin to date, I’ve never had any options, I just create a redirect and it always defaults to 301. I’ve tried to get the advanced options to show up in multiple browsers, deactivated other plugins, cleared the WordPress cache, etc. I’m on a MacBook. Any other ideas I can try? Thank you!

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]