Hi
You can use both.
-Modsecurity: use it to handle generic rules.
-NinjaFirewall: use it to handle all the rest, including WP related rules and policies.
The difference is that, even if NinjaFirewall and Modsecurity work before WordPress, NinjaFirewall knows what’s going on with your blog. For instance, it could detect and block a user attempting to gain administrator privileges while Modsecurity couldn’t. It can also do real monitoring with its File Guard feature.
Also, each site can have a different configuration with NinjaFirewall, while Modsecurity will apply to the whole server (which is fine for generic rules).
More details about its options and policies: https://blog.nintechnet.com/securing-wordpress-with-a-web-application-firewall-ninjafirewall/
Both can work well together.
Thread Starter
Anonymous User 14978628
(@anonymized-14978628)
Hi, thanks for explaining this. What about if one is using the Cloudflare WAF? Would it still be of any benefit using this plugin? Or what about the other way around. Could this plugin be used as a replacement for the Cloudflare WAF?
NinjaFirewall can be used as a replacement for any cloud-based WAF. As I mentioned in my previous message, one of its advantages is that it knows what’s going on with your WP install and more generally, with all your files and DB.
Thread Starter
Anonymous User 14978628
(@anonymized-14978628)
That’s good to know, thanks.
Thread Starter
Anonymous User 14978628
(@anonymized-14978628)
Just saw this article:
https://blogvault.net/an-in-depth-review-of-ninjafirewall-against-common-wordpress-attacks/
Basically it says that firewalls with predefined rules aren’t always effective as attackers can just modify signatures to avoid detection. I guess in such cases a cloud WAF would work better due to more rapid updates?
The article is not correct. NinjaFirewall does not only use rules, its uses heuristic detection and that works pretty well to block 0-day vulnerabilities. Rules can be updated automatically and hourly.
Thread Starter
Anonymous User 14978628
(@anonymized-14978628)
Perhaps the article is out of date then as it said Ninjafirewall failed one of the tests stating:
NinjaFirewall didn’t stop the attack.
We think it was because NinjaFirewall has a list of rules for what attacks should look like, in a section called Rules Editor.
I don’t know, but I recommend that you make your own tests. It’s always better to verify yourself 🙂
