It was a mistake, sorry, all works fine for me too !
I can’t get mine to work and could use some help.
@stresstopower,
At the top of the forum topic I posted some videos that will guide you to setup the messages.
I’m sorry, but I can’t find the video. I’m new here.
I didn’t find the video helpful. I found it hard to hear and it didn’t seem to address my problem. My problem is the plugin doesn’t send out any messages. Nothing. I found an article elsewhere that said it might help to use MailGun instead of what my site was using, so I went to the trouble of setting MailGun up and apparently it’s happy with the way I did it, but the emails from the plugin are still not going out. Emails from my contact form are, I used that as a check.
Erin
(@thelawstudentswife)
I also have this problem. Even though all of my settings match what is shown in the video (and the notification box is checked by default), new commenters are not being added to my subscription page AND they are not being notified of responses via email. HELP!
I hired someone from JustAnswer to solve the problem. Apparently the problem was my server didn’t allow the use of the phpmail() function that the plugin was using. The JustAnswer fellow added a plugin that replaces phpmail with smtp. I don’t completely understand it, but it works fine now. I can give you the email of the fellow if you like — he was easily worth what I paid him. If you’re interested just leave a comment at cheerfulmonk.com and I will email you his address.