Only homepage redirection not working

I ma using redirection extensively across the site and it works just fine. But for some reason, I am unable to redirect users away from the homepage for logged-in users.

But I am able to direct logged out users to the homepage if they try to access a restricted page.

What could I be missing?

Redirection that does not work: https://gyazo.com/7765360a2b18617b0321f1dae74b7137

Redirection that works: https://gyazo.com/ca3009ffc8da06d003e9ef35852aa067

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]