Only listing 5 posts

I’m using the latest version of list category posts. Regardless of shortcode context it only lists 5 posts in a category.

I’m using the Modernize theme by Goodlayers.

site: churchproductionresources.com/wp

example page: http://churchproductionresources.com/wp/free-resources/helpful-articles/

I’ve tried using numberposts=100. I’ve also tried leaving it out completely. Either way… 5 posts displayed.

Thanks in advance!

http://ww.wp.xz.cn/plugins/list-category-posts/