Recommended Theme?

I’m in the initial phases of migrating a website on to WordPress and would like to solicit feedback and recommendations for a responsive theme? The site is http://hickoryhills.com/ and I would like to keep the page layout similar to what is presented today. I’m not opposed to paying for a premium-theme, as long as it is highly customizable should our membership change requirements on me (which is likely).

I’m fairly new to WordPress and my background is more in C++, Java, and Cobol (not HTML, CSS, PHP, etc), so any advice and guidance would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks WP community for your help and support!

Dusty B.