Redirection changes URL, results in 404

I need to redirect to a URL that has a ‘ in it. When I enter the URL into the Redirection plugin, it shows the ‘ but it removes it from the actual redirect URL. See here:

http://universaltheosophy.com/redirect-issue.png

See that the URL has “God’s” in it, but the Redirection plugin changes this to “Gods”, hence the URL results in a 404. Not sure if there’s a way to fix this.