Reply button not working in Gmail

Hello,
after successfully sending test message from my contact form 7 i’m redirecting it from [email protected] to [email protected]. Reply button is working OK in my host provider webmail but NOT in gmail. It’s using address [email protected] from “FROM” field instead of [your-email] field in my contact form. Additional header is added as required in plugin documentation.

What might be a problem here?

Print-screens available on: https://app.box.com/s/mnsd72gy0x9ywrq6zqhoyny3kgegymay

Thank you for your suggestions.