Good news. I’ve figured out how to do this minus separate template files by adding this to my page.php. I would still love to be able to do away with the separate sidebar files altogether to further simplify so thoughts are welcome!
<?php
if ( is_page('Me') || $post->post_parent == '2168') {
get_sidebar('me');
} elseif (is_page('Content') || $post->post_parent == '2175') {
get_sidebar('content');
} elseif (is_page('Site') || $post->post_parent == '2172') {
get_sidebar('site');
} elseif (is_page('Links') || $post->post_parent == '2965') {
get_sidebar('links');
} else {
get_sidebar();
}
?>
I just thought I’d update this with a related find. This blog post has an even cleaner method of calling multiple sidebars: http://marstonstudio.com/2007/07/17/multiple-wordpress-widget-sidebars
I no longer have multiple sidebar files in my theme directory but I am still interested in a smarter/neater way of doing this.