[Plugin: W3 Total Cache] Page Cache setting for SSL

I’m having an odd issue, but was able to pin point to W3 Total Cache Page Cache.

Here’s the issue: https breaks the formatting of logged-off front page. Once the page cache is cleared, it loads fine (until cache is made, then break again)

This is how I pinpoint: All pages load fine in http. When I set to https, all pages would load just fine, EXCEPT the front page. Once I’m logged in, I can see the front page with https (and all pages). So I cleared the cache on Page Cache, then https (logged-off) front page loads fine, but once cache is built again, the page breaks.

This is an odd behavior. I turned off caching for the front-page (“Don’t cache front page” => checked), which seems to be working, but I WANT to cache front page as this is the landing page. I have “Cache SSL requests” checked.

Any ideas? Your input will be greatly appreciated.