Austin,
Selecting activate fixed the issue. Thanks for your help!
You should be able to open a second tab in your browser and got to http://www.yoursitehere.com/wp-login.php and see the results.
Sorry, but I had to turn the plugin off since it has been a while. Let me know if you want to see how the site is acting with the plugin on and i can re-activate it. Thanks.
PS – If this is an issue that could be solved by using the pro version let me know. I am always open to support independent coders making useful products.