I’ve removed any other plugins that have a social login component but the “Login with Facebook” still hovers. It does this on the homepage and logs in just fine and so I don’t think that is the issue. I deactivated simple-press, and then suddenly the login worked on that page. I’m pretty certain it is the interaction between simple press. Is there perhaps a snippet of code I could drop into simple press to hide the the social login on this page? And then I could just manually add the links to the top of the page.
