That’s exactly what I meant, sorry for not being clear. As you can see from my review, the other plugin worked better for me, but I did have one theme driven issue.
I do think it’s great that you are responding and supporting your users. Will update my original review.
Thank you very much for your response. The only setting that is driven by the theme is the buttons being left-justified. I did indeed ask on the forum about this issue. It was in connection to MaxButtons Social Share Button plugin, which, unlike yours, makes buttons that 1) look much better 2) do not require a second click 3) work like a charm – no weird sizing 3) the plugin is not spammy at all. That plugin is worth fixing. Yours, not so much.
In short, I do recommend MaxButtons.