@jhatcher12 What I’ve done to get around the page being added to the main menu:
When the page is created again, go to Appearance > Menus and either remove the page from the menu there or rename it (empty name field).
After that save the menu and it shouldn’t come back, but leave the page as is in the pages-menu, otherwise it’ll be re-added (so basically just ignore that entire page after it’s created).
Awesome, thanks for the quick reply!