Whoops, here is some extra information. My site currently uses custom menus (imported during the import process), and I have tried clicking each individual link in those menus to see if they were just the source of the redirect…
When I do this it brings me to the correct location
xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx/arbitrary page#
When I view the site live and click the menu links it redirects to my .com blog (lowerhudsondiscgolf.com)