ghalexweb

I have found a pattern for this problem.
1. Doesnt’t matter how many comments you have;
2. Doesnt’t matter what theme you have installed;
3. Comments show up in order if you disable threaded comments;

By default, most of the themes with threaded comments support have that “Reply” button removed when a comment reaches 3/4/5 (depending of your options) levels of comments. That’s great but how about the edit_comments.php section from the admin area? The reply link is still there even if you reach your selected number of levels.
So, if you reply to a comment that has reached the max numbers of comments, from the admin area, this comment will show up in the bottom of the page and messes everything up.
I’ve made a test post to see what i mean, i can easily replicate the problem.

Very sorry for my bad english, i hope you guys can understand what i have just said:)

Ipstenu – no, it’s the only one with almost 300 comments.
I kind of solved this problem.
So, the comments listing looked like this in my case:

Comment 1 – Day 1
Comment 5 – Day 2 (reply to Comment 1)
Comment 7 – Day 4 (reply to Comment 1)
Comment 2 – Day 1
Comment 9 – Day 5
Comment 10 – Day 6
Comment 3 – Day 2
Comment 6 – Day 3 (reply to Comment 3)
Comment 8 – Day 10 (reply to comment 6)
Comment 4 – Day 2

I deleted every comment under day 6 (comment 3, 6, 8 and 4) and now everything works like it should.

Ipsteanu – please check this page When I post not as a reply, as a “new comment”, it appears in the middle of the page, not in the bottom like it should.

rishk789, have you solved your problem? Any solutions yet?