Well, I figured out the problem. Evidently, having more than 25 questions with Answers Type as Rich Text will cause the %AMOUNT_CORRECT% and %POINT_SCORE% count to be off. That seems to be a glitch in the plug-in. Once I changed the answer options to Text Answers then the count was correct. I’ve tried different things and that is what it came down to.
What is more infuriating is that I had to change my Answers Type to Text Answers, which wiped out all of my answer options and I had to re-enter them back in. Not convenient when there are multiple quizzes with 40 questions and multiple choice answers.