My pleasure. The only way to get a better product is to make clear reports that you can act on, right?
I’ve found out what the problem was on my end; the Jetpack option “Let readers use WordPress.com, Twitter, Facebook, or Google+ accounts to comment”. When I disabled that, the option shows up.
I am seeing the same issue. I should note that I did not activate the check box when it was offered, and now cannot find the setting anywhere.
I am seeing the same issue, regardless of theme.