I’m not sure why this was marked as resolved before I had a chance to reply…
I have everything setup as you noted above. I didn’t change anything, but it seems to be working now. I originally tested more than a week after adding the records, so it wasn’t a DNS propagation issue. Not sure what the issue was, but it seems to be working now.
@fourandhalfgarrett you might check yours again, maybe it’s magically working now as well!