>>> Any more ideas?
Yes. Here’s one . . .
Go to the plugin compatibility page and deactivate any plugins you have that aren’t on it. 🙂
For me, it was the Depokerizer plugin.
Deactivated that and I’m good. 🙂
I tried Kafkaesqui’s fix that he linked to.
It updated the comment totals to date. But still doesn’t update with future comments.
Any more ideas?